Decide out a cell utility you are familiar with, and assess

264

C H A P T E R

13

What’s it? Mobile originate encompasses techni­ cal and nontechnical actions that include: establishing the scrutinize and feel of the cell utility (including cell apps, WebApps, digital actuality, and games), creating the aes­ thetic structure of the user interface, set up­ ing the rhythm of user interplay, defining the total architectural construction, build­ ing the notify material and functionality that re­ aspect  within the structure, and planning the navigation that occurs within the cell product.

Who does it? Gadget engineers, graphic de­ signers, notify material developers, safety special­ ists, and other stakeholders all take part in the introduction of a cell originate model.

Why is it fundamental? Assemble helps you to cre­ ate a model that will even also be assessed for quality and improved sooner than notify material and code are generated, assessments are performed, and stay

users was focused on tidy numbers. Assemble is the set where cell app quality is established.

What are the steps? Mobile originate encom­ passes six fundamental steps that are pushed by infor­ mation received at some stage in requirements modeling and are described on this chapter.

What’s the work product? A originate model that encompasses notify material, aesthetics, archi­ tecture, interface, navigation, and part­ stage originate factors is the fundamental work product that is produced at some stage in cell originate.

How stay I make particular I’ve done it correct? Every element of the originate model is reviewed in an effort to show errors, inconsistencies, or omissions. In addition, replacement choices are even handed, and the stage to which the present originate model will outcome in effective implementation on various utility plat­ forms and devices can be assessed.

Q u i c good ample L o o good ample

exquisite originate . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 277 structure originate . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .278 challenges . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .265 cloud computing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .273 part-stage originate . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .282 notify material structure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .279 notify material originate . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 277 notify material objects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 277 context-mindful apps . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .274 originate

simplest practices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .285 errors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .272

pyramid . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .275 quality . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .282

graphic originate . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 277 cell architectures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .273 cell pattern life cycle . . . . . . . . . . . .268 model-stumble on-controller . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .279 navigation originate . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .280 quality checklist . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .285 technical issues . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .266 user interface originate . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .270 WebApp structure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .279

good ample e y c o n c e p t s

Assemble for Mobility

Mobile devices—smartphones, capsules, wearable devices, handheld gaming devices, and other truly knowledgeable products—private was the fresh face of comput- ing. Per Pew Research Heart [Pew18], within the United States 77 percent of people private a smartphone and 50 percent of people private a tablet computer of some kind. Mobile computing has was a dominant force.

CHAPTER 13 DESIGN FOR MOBILITY 265

In his authoritative book on Web originate, Jakob Nielsen [Nie00] states: “There are in actual fact two basic approaches to originate: the ingenious supreme of expressing your self and the engineering supreme of fixing a order for a buyer.” Right by the fundamental decade of cell pattern, the ingenious belief used to be the technique that many developers chose. Assemble came about in an advert hoc manner and used to be primarily performed as HTML used to be generated. Assemble superior out of an ingenious imaginative and prescient that superior as Online net page construc- tion came about.

Even at this time, many developers utilize cell apps as poster kids for “restricted originate.” They argue that immediacy and volatility of the cell market mitigate in opposition to formal originate; that originate evolves as an utility is built (coded), and that barely minute time ought to quiet be spent on creating a detailed originate model. This argu- ment has advantage, nevertheless only for barely easy apps. When notify material and feature are complex; when the scale of the cell app encompasses many of or hundreds of notify material objects, capabilities, and prognosis classes; and when the success of the app will private an instantaneous influence on the success of the business, originate can no longer and ought to quiet no longer be taken flippantly. This actuality leads us to Nielsen’s second technique—“the engineering supreme of fixing a order for a buyer.”

13.1 th e ch a L L e ng e s

Though cell devices private many parts in basic with one one more, their users primarily private very totally different perceptions of what parts they seek information from to be bundled in each and every. Some users seek information from the similar parts that are provided on their private comput- ers. Others specialize within the freedom that portable devices give them and gladly bag the decreased functionality within the cell model of a well-recognized utility product. Mild others seek information from uncommon experiences no longer that that you must well imagine on used computing or entertain- ment devices. The user’s thought of “goodness” will be more fundamental than any of the technical quality dimensions of the cell product itself.

13.1.1 Fashion Concerns Savor all computing devices, cell platforms are differentiated by the utility they raise—a aggregate of working machine (e.g., Android or iOS) and a runt sub- set of dwelling of the many of of hundreds of cell utility products that provide a extremely broad replacement of functionality. Fresh instruments allow people with minute formal training to manufacture and sell apps alongside other apps developed by tidy teams of utility developers.

Regardless that apps could well also also be developed by amateurs, many utility engineers articulate that MobileApps are amongst primarily the most bright utility systems being built at this time [Voa12]. Mobile platforms are very complex. Every the Android and iOS working systems private over 12 million lines of code. Mobile devices primarily private mini brows- ers that will even no longer music the plump set of dwelling of notify material accessible on a Online net page. Varied cell devices utilize totally different working systems and platform-dependent pattern environments. Mobile devices have a tendency to private smaller screen sizes and more totally different screen sizes than private computer systems. This could well also unbiased require increased attention to user inter- face originate factors, including decisions to limit music of some notify material. MobileApps

266 PART TWO MODELING

could private to be designed to address shut intermittent connectivity outages into story, boundaries on battery life, and other instrument constraints1 [Whi08].

Gadget parts in cell computing environments are inclined to trade their areas whereas their apps are working. To assist connectivity in nomadic acquire- works,2 coordination mechanisms for discovering devices, exchanging records, sustaining safety and dialog integrity, and synchronizing actions could private to be developed. There is continuously a replace-off between safety and other parts of the cell product originate.

In addition, utility engineers need to title the valid originate replace-offs between the expressive strength of the MobileApp and stakeholder safety concerns. Developers need to scrutinize to stumble on algorithms (or adapt existing algorithms) that are vitality effi- cient to preserve battery strength when that that you must well imagine. Middleware could well also unbiased ought to quiet be created to permit totally various kinds of cell devices to consult with one one more within the similar cell networks [Gru00].

Gadget engineers ought to quiet craft a user trip that takes perfect thing about instrument traits and context-mindful capabilities. The nonfunctional requirements (e.g., safety, performance, usability) are quite totally different from these for either WebApps or desktop utility capabilities. There is continuously a replace-off between safety and other parts of the cell originate. Testing cell utility products (Chapter 21) legit- vides extra challenges because of users seek information from that they’re going to work in a tidy number of bodily totally different environments. Portability is one more order for utility engi- neers as there are several standard instrument platforms. It is costly to construct and give a enhance to capabilities for a pair of instrument platforms [Was10].

13.1.2 Technical Concerns The cheap of including Web capabilities to day to day devices such as phones, cameras, and TVs is reworking the technique people gain admission to records and utilize community companies [Sch11]. Amongst the totally different technical issues that MobileApps ought to quiet contend with are the following:

A couple of hardware and utility platforms. It is in no scheme unheard of for a cell product to run on many varied platforms (each and every cell and situation- ary) with various differing ranges of functionality. The causes for these differences are in piece since the hardware and utility accessible are rather totally different from instrument to instrument. This could enhance each and every pattern price and time. It could well perchance make configuration management (Chapter 22) more sophisticated. Many pattern frameworks and programming languages. Mobile products are at the second being written in different obvious programming or script- ing languages (e.g., HTML5, JavaScript, Java, Swift, and C#) for a mess of standard pattern frameworks (e.g., Android, iOS, Xamarin, Home windows, AngularJS). Very few cell devices allow direct pattern on a instrument itself. As a replacement, cell developers in total utilize emulators working on desktop

1 Readily accessible at http://www.devx.com/SpecialReports/Article/37693. 2 Nomadic networks private changing connections to cell devices or servers.

CHAPTER 13 DESIGN FOR MOBILITY 267

pattern systems. These emulators could well also unbiased or could well also unbiased no longer accurately replicate the boundaries of the instrument itself. Skinny-consumer capabilities are primarily more straightforward to port to a pair of devices than capabilities designed to run completely on the cell instrument. Many app stores with totally different principles and instruments. Every cell platform has its private app retailer and its private requirements for accepting apps (e.g., Apple,3 Google,4 Microsoft,5 and Amazon6 submit their private requirements). Fashion of a cell product for a pair of platforms need to proceed individually, and each and every model of the app wishes its private requirements knowledgeable. Very short pattern cycles. The marketplace for cell products is very aggressive, and utility engineers are inclined to make utilize of agile pattern processes when building MobileApps to be able to gash pattern time [Was10]. Person interface boundaries and complexities of interplay with sensors and cameras. Mobile devices private smaller screen sizes than private computer systems and a richer set of dwelling of interplay potentialities (touch, gesture, digicam, and an excellent deal of others.) and usage eventualities in step with context consciousness. The kind and appearance of the user interface will seemingly be dictated by the character of platform-train pattern instruments [Rot02]. Permitting trim devices to work along with trim spaces affords the doable to manufacture customized, networked, high-fidelity utility platforms such as these seen by merging smartphones and vehicle infotainment systems.7

Effective utilize of context. Customers seek information from MobileApps to raise customized user experiences in step with the physical set of a instrument relating to the accessible community parts. Person interface originate and context-mindful applica- tions are discussed in increased element in Allotment 13.4. Energy management. Battery life will seemingly be one amongst primarily the most limiting constraints on many cell devices. Backlighting, learning and writing to memory, the usage of wi-fi connections, making utilize of specialised hardware, and processor run all influence strength usage and ought to quiet be even handed by utility developers [Mei09]. Security and privacy items and policies. Wireless dialog is dif- ficult to provide protection to from eavesdropping. Combating man-in-the-center-attacks8 in automobile capabilities could well also also be major to the protection of the users [Bos11]. Info saved on a cell instrument are topic to theft if a instrument is lost or a malicious app is downloaded. Gadget policies that amplify the stage of con- fidence within the protection and privacy of a MobileApp primarily gash the usability of the app and the spontaneity of the dialog amongst users [Rot02].

3 https://developer.apple.com/appstore/pointers.html. 4 http://developer.android.com/distribute/googleplay/submit/getting willing.html. 5 http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/ff941089%28v=vs.92%29.aspx. 6 https://developer.amazon.com/apps-and-games/app-submission/android. 7 When utilized in an automobile setting, trim devices ought to quiet have the option to restrict gain admission to to

companies that will even unbiased distract the motive force and allow hands-free operation when a automobile is sharp [Bos11].

8 These attacks involve a third celebration intercepting communications between two trusted sources and impersonating one or each and every of the occasions.

268 PART TWO MODELING

Computational and storage boundaries. There is sizable curiosity within the usage of cell devices to manipulate house environmental and safety companies. When MobileApps are allowed to work along with devices and companies of their environ- ment, it’s a ways easy to crush the cell instrument (storage, processing run, strength consumed) with the sheer volume of information [Spa11]. Developers could well also unbiased prefer to scrutinize for programming shortcuts and strategy of lowering the demands made on processor and memory sources. Purposes that rely on exterior companies. Constructing skinny cell clients suggests the necessity to rely on Web provider services and cloud storage companies. This could enhance concerns for each and every records or provider accessibility and safety [Rot02]. Testing complexity. Mobile products that run totally on the instrument could well also also be tested the usage of used utility making an are trying out programs (Chapters 19 and 20) or the usage of emulators working on private computer systems. Skinny-consumer MobileApps are severely bright to take a look at. They present many of the similar making an are trying out chal- lenges music in WebApps, nevertheless they private got the further concerns associated with transmission of information by Web gateways and telephone networks [Was10]. Testing of cell utility products will be discussed in Chapter 21.

13.2 Mo b i L e De v e L o p M e n t Li f e cyc L e

Burns [Bur16] and her Microsoft colleagues direct a advice for an iterative cell SDLC that contains five fundamental phases:

Inception. Needs, parts, and capabilities of the cell product are identified to choose the scope and the scale of the fundamental increment or feasibility prototype. Developers and stakeholders could private to take into accout of human, social, cultural, and organizational actions that will even unbiased music hidden parts of the users’ wishes and private an influence on the business targets and functionality of the proposed cell product.

Assemble. The originate involves architectural originate, navigation originate, interface originate, notify material originate. Developers outline the app user trip the usage of screen mockups and paper prototypes to assist manufacture an actual user interface originate that will address shut totally different screen sizes and capabilities into story apart from the capabilities of each and every targeted platform.

Fashion. Mobile utility is coded, purposeful and nonfunctional. Test cases are created and executed, and usability and accessibility experiences are con- ducted as the product evolves.

Stabilization. Most cell products battle by a series of prototypes: feasibility prototype, supposed as a proof of belief with in all probability simplest one whole common sense direction by the utility; alpha prototype, which contains the functionality for minimum viable product; beta prototype, which is largely whole and contains most tested functionality; and lastly the initiating candidate, which contains all required functionality, for which all scheduled assessments had been executed, and which is willing for overview by the product owner.

CHAPTER 13 DESIGN FOR MOBILITY 269

Deployment. Once stabilized, a cell product is reviewed by a business app retailer and made accessible within the marketplace and download. For apps supposed for interior com- pany utilize simplest, a product owner overview could well also very successfully be all that is required sooner than deployment.

Mobile pattern makes utilize of an agile, spiral engineering route of model. The phases will no longer be executed in notify love they’d perchance be if cell pattern used to be done the usage of the waterfall model. The phases described above are visited persistently as developers and stakeholders make higher belief of the user wishes and product business dreams.

Formulating Mobile Tool Requirements

The scene: A gathering room. The fundamental assembly to title

requirements for a cell model of the SafeHome WebApp.

The avid gamers: Jamie Lazar, utility crew member; Vinod Raman, utility crew mem­ ber; Ed Robbins, utility crew member; Doug Miller, utility engineering supervisor; three contributors of advertising and marketing; a product engineering consultant; and a facilitator.

The dialog: Facilitator (pointing at whiteboard): So that’s the present checklist of objects and companies for the house safety feature music within the WebApp.

Vinod (interrupting): My belief is that of us prefer SafeHome functionality to be accessible from cell devices as successfully . . . including the house safety feature?

Marketing and marketing person: Yes, that’s correct . . . we’ll need to add that functionality and address shut a peep at to make it context mindful to assist personalize the user trip.

Facilitator: Context mindful in what sense?

Marketing and marketing person: Folk could well also are seeking to utilize a smartphone as an replacement of the alter panel and steer clear of going online to a net spot when they are in the driveway at house. Or they’d also no longer prefer all family contributors to private gain admission to to the mas­ ter alter dashboard for the machine from their phones.

Facilitator: Attain it’s seemingly you’ll unbiased private train cell devices in solutions?

Marketing and marketing person: Successfully, all smartphones could perchance be good. We are in a position to private a Web model done, so obtained’t the MobileApp run on all of them?

Jamie: No longer rather. If we took a cell cell telephone browser technique, we are in a position to have the option to reuse various our WebApp functionality. Nonetheless take into accout, smartphone screen sizes vary, and in enlighten that they’d also unbiased or could well also unbiased no longer all private the similar touch capabilities. So, at the very least we would want to manufacture a cell net spot that takes the parts of every and every instrument into story.

Ed: Possibly we ought to quiet manufacture the cell model of the acquire spot first.

Marketing and marketing person: OK, nevertheless a cell net spot solution wasn’t what we had in solutions.

Vinod: Every cell platform appears to be like to private its private uncommon pattern environ­ ment, too.

Manufacturing to find: Attain we restrict MobileApp pattern to simplest one or two styles of smartphones?

Marketing and marketing person: I appreciate that will even work. Unless I’m flawed, the smartphone market is dominated by two smartphone platforms correct now.

Jamie: There’s also safety to fright about. We higher ensure that an outsider can’t hack into the machine, disarm it, and rob the set or worse. Also, a cell telephone could perchance gain lost or stolen more easily than a computer.

safehoMe

270 PART TWO MODELING

13.2.1 Person Interface Assemble Mobile instrument users seek information from that minimal learning time will be required to grasp a MobileApp. To whole this, MobileApp designers utilize fixed icon representations and placement for the duration of a pair of platforms. In addition, designers could private to be sensitive to the user’s expectation of privacy with regard to the music of private records on the screen of the cell instrument. Contact and gesture interfaces, along with sophis- ticated explain input and facial recognition, are maturing mercurial [Shu12] and private already was piece of the user interface clothier’s toolbox.

Appropriate and ethical stress to provide for gain admission to by all people suggests that cell instrument interfaces prefer to story for tag differences, cultural differences, fluctuate- ences in computing trip, elderly users, and users with disabilities (e.g., visual, aural, mobility). The effects of unfortunate usability could well also unbiased mean that users can no longer whole their projects or is no longer going to be happy with the outcomes. This means the importance of user-centered originate actions in each and every of the usability areas (user interface, exterior accent interface, and provider interface). Accessibility is a extremely fundamental originate topic and could private to be even handed when user-centered originate is applied.

In searching to satisfy stakeholder usability expectations, MobileApp developers ought to quiet are trying to acknowledge these inquiries to evaluate the out-of-the-field readiness of the instrument:

∙ Is the user interface fixed for the duration of capabilities? ∙ Is the instrument interoperable with totally different community companies? ∙ Is the instrument acceptable relating to stakeholder values9 within the aim market situation?

Eisenstein [Eis01] claims that the utilize of abstract, platform-neutral items to direct a user interface vastly facilitates the pattern of fixed, usable multiplatform user interfaces for cell devices. Three items in train are precious. A platform model describes the constraints imposed by each and every platform to be supported. A presen- tation model describes the appears to be like to be like of the user interface. The job model is a structured representation of the projects a user wishes to develop to satisfy her job dreams. Within the top case, model-primarily primarily based originate (Chapter 9) involves the introduction of databases that private the

9 Mark, ethical preferences, unbiased preferences, cognitive beliefs.

Doug: Very valid.

Marketing and marketing: Nonetheless we quiet need the similar stage of safety . . . unbiased also be clear to cease an out­ sider from getting into with a stolen cell telephone.

Ed: That’s more straightforward acknowledged than done and . . .

Facilitator (interrupting): Let’s no longer fright about these particulars but.

(Doug, serving as the recorder for the assembly, makes a suitable sign.)

Facilitator: As a starting level, will we title which parts of WebApp safety feature are wanted within the MobileApp and which is willing to ought to quiet be newly created? Then we are in a position to de­ cide what number of cell platforms we are in a position to sup­ port and when we are in a position to poke forward on this project.

(The neighborhood spends the following 20 minutes refining and expanding the particulars of the house safety feature.)

CHAPTER 13 DESIGN FOR MOBILITY 271

items and has utility give a enhance to for producing user interfaces for a pair of devices auto- matically. Using model-primarily primarily based originate ways could well also also relief designers acknowledge and accommodate the uncommon contexts and context modifications that are music in cell computing. Without an abstract description of a user interface, the pattern of cell user interfaces could well also also be error susceptible and time drinking.

13.2.2 Lessons Realized de Sá and Carriço [Des08] contend that there are fundamental differences between build- ing feeble utility and organising cell capabilities. Gadget engineers can no longer proceed to utilize the similar feeble ways they private got used and seek information from them to be a hit. They counsel three approaches for the originate of cell capabilities:

Usage Scenarios. Described in Chapter 12, usage eventualities need to assist in solutions context variables (set, user, and instrument) and transitions between contextual eventualities (e.g., user moves from bedroom to kitchen or switches from stylus to a finger). de Sá and Carriço private identified a set of dwelling of scenario-variable forms that ought to quiet be even handed in organising the user eventualities—areas and settings, motion and posture, devices and usages, workloads and distractions, user preferences.

Mobile Person Interface Assemble Concerns Assemble picks private an influence on performance and

ought to quiet be examined early within the user interface de­ signal route of. Ivo Weevers [Wee11] posted several cell user–interface originate practices which private confirmed to be commended when designing cell capabilities:

∙ Account for user interface tag signatures. Differentiate the app from its competitors. Create the core signature parts of the tag primarily the most responsive, because of users will utilize them over and over.

∙ Point of curiosity the portfolio of products. Target the platforms that are most fundamental to the success of the app and the corporate. No longer all platforms private the similar replacement of users.

∙ Name the core user tales. Create utilize of how that require stakeholders to prioritize their wishes in enlighten to gash a prolonged checklist of requirements and to assist in solutions the constrained sources accessible on cell devices.

∙ Optimize user interface flows and parts. Customers stay no longer desire to wait. Name doable bottlenecks in user work skedaddle and ensure that the user is given an indication of growth when delays occur. Create clear that that the time to music screen parts is justified relating to user advantages.

∙ Account for scaling principles. Resolve the decisions that will be used when records to be displayed is simply too tidy to suit on the screen. Man­ getting older functionality, aesthetics, usability, and performance is a persevering with balancing act.

∙ Person performance dashboard. The dashboard is used to discuss the product’s present issue completion (e.g., replacement of utilize tales implemented), its performance relative to its targets, and in all probability comparisons to its competitors.

∙ Champion-devoted user interface engineer- ing talents. It is fundamental to worship that the implementation of structure, graphics, and anima­ tion has performance implications. Solutions to interleave rendering of music items and program execution could well also also be commended.

information

272 PART TWO MODELING

Ethnographic Commentary.10 Here is a broadly used scheme for gathering informa- tion about consultant users of a utility product as it’s a ways being designed. It is primarily sophisticated to peek users as they trade contexts, since the observer need to practice users for long sessions of time, one thing that will raise privacy concerns.11 A com- plicating part is that users seem to whole projects in one more scheme in non-public settings than in social settings. The identical users could well also unbiased ought to quiet be seen performing projects in mul- tiple contexts whereas monitoring transitions, apart from recording user reactions to the modifications.

Low-Constancy Paper Prototypes (e.g., playing cards or Put up-it notes). Here is a price-effective usability evaluation technique in user interface originate that will even also be used sooner than any programming takes set. It is fundamental for these prototypes to be similar in size and weight and for their utilize to be allowed in various contexts. Furthermore it could be fundamental that the sketches or text displays be valid to size and for the final product to be of high quality. Placement and size of user interface widgets (e.g., buttons or scrollbars) need to be designed so that they is no longer going to disappear when users prolong their displays by zooming. The interplay kind (e.g., stylus, joy stick, touch screen) wishes to be emu- lated within the low-fidelity prototype (e.g., colored pen or push pin) to seem at placement and ease of utilize. Later prototypes could well also unbiased then be created to run on the targeted cell devices as soon as the structure and placement factors had been resolved.

MobileApp Assemble Errors Joh Koester [Koe12] posts several examples of cell originate practices

that ought to quiet be prevented: ∙ Kitchen sink. Motivate remote from including too many parts

to the app and too many widgets on the screen. Easy is understandable. Easy is marketable.

∙ Inconsistency. To handbook clear of this, set of dwelling requirements for net page navigation, menu utilize, buttons, tabs, and other user­interface parts. Follow a uniform scrutinize and feel.

∙ Overdesigning. Be ruthless when designing apps. Steal away needless parts and wasteful graphics. Attain no longer be tempted to be able to add parts unbiased because of you mediate you ought to quiet.

∙ Lack of run. Customers stay no longer care about instrument constraints—they are seeking to stumble on issues mercurial. Preload what that you must well. Put away with what is no longer wanted.

∙ Verbiage. Unnecessarily long, wordy menus and screen displays are indications of a cell product that has no longer been tested with users and developers who private no longer spent ample time belief the user’s job.

∙ Nonstandard interplay. One reason within the encourage of focusing on a platform is to address shut perfect thing about the user’s trip with the technique issues are done on that platform. The set requirements exist utilize them. This wishes to be balanced with the prefer to private an utility seem and be­ private the similar technique on a pair of devices when that that you must well imagine.

∙ Serve-and-FAQ-itis. Adding online relief is no longer the technique to restore a poorly designed user inter­ face. Create clear that it’s seemingly you’ll unbiased private tested your app with your targeted users and repaired the identified defects.

information

10 Ethnographi